Cracked screens. Batteries that die before lunch. Apps that take ages to load. These everyday frustrations have a way of sparking the same question: Should I fix my phone, or is it time to move on?
In 2025, the answer isn’t as clear-cut as it once was. Fast in-store repairs and stronger warranties make it easier to keep your current phone running, while a booming certified pre-owned market offers affordable replacements that feel brand new without the full price tag.
The choice comes down to the type of damage, the age and performance of your device, your budget, and even your environmental values. Let’s break it down.
Repair or Replace: Quick-View Guide
| Issue | iPhone 14–16 | Samsung Galaxy S22–S25 | Google Pixel 7–9 | Other Recent Androids | Older Models (4+ years old) |
| Cracked screen (display works) | Repair | Repair | Repair | Repair/td> | Depends |
| Cracked screen (unresponsive) | Repair | Repair | Repair | Repair/td> | Depends |
| Battery capacity <80% | Repair | Repair | Repair | Repair/td> | Depends |
| Charging port not working | Repair | Repair | Depends | Depends | Depends |
| Rear camera glass cracked | Repair | Repair | Repair | Repair/td> | Depends |
| Camera module failure (OIS/focus) | Repair | Repair | Repair | Repair/td> | Depends |
| Face ID/Touch ID failure | Depends | N/A | N/A | N/A/td> | Replace |
| Speaker/mic failure | Repair | Repair | Repair | Repair/td> | Depends |
| Severe water damage | Depends | Depends | Depends | Depends | Replace |
| Outdated OS/no security updates | Replace | Replace | Replace | Replace | Replace |
| Multiple issues (2–3 components) | Replace | Replace | Replace | Replace | Replace |
Legend
- Repair: Generally cost-effective and practical for this issue.
- Replace: Repair costs likely exceed the device’s value, or performance won’t fully recover.
- Depends: Viability hinges on:
- Device age and remaining software support
- Cost and availability of replacement parts
- Whether the issue is combined with other faults
Tip: As a general rule, if a repair will cost less than half the price of replacing your phone with a similar model, it’s usually the better call.
Signs It’s Time to Repair Your Phone
When the damage is isolated to one issue—especially if the phone is relatively new—repair is often the fastest, most cost-effective solution.
Minor screen damage or cracks
If your phone’s display is intact but the glass is cracked, a screen replacement can restore it to like-new condition. This is one of the most common and affordable repairs, especially when done by trained specialists like Mobile Klinik’s device repair team.
Battery not holding a charge
Batteries naturally degrade over time—a 3-year-old phone can easily drop to under 80% capacity. A quick battery replacement can extend its usable life by years, and it’s far cheaper than buying new.
Download the Device Check-Up app for the initial diagnosis.
Software issues or glitches
Slowdowns, freezing, or random shutdowns are sometimes caused by corrupted software, not failing hardware. A reset or OS reinstall can often clear up deeper system issues, while tools like the Device Check-Up app help by running quick diagnostics, checking battery, storage, and connectivity health, and offering personalized optimization tips to keep your phone performing smoothly.
When repair makes the most sense:
- Your phone is under three years old.
- The problem is limited to one or two components.
- Replacement parts are readily available.
Is your phone not working?
Get a free phone diagnosis in 5 minutes when you visit us in-store.
Learn more
Signs It’s Time to Replace Your Phone
Sometimes repair costs and limitations outweigh the benefits, especially if your phone is aging out of software and hardware support.
Major hardware failure
Damage to the logic board, internal memory, or advanced camera modules can be costly and may not restore the phone to full function.
Outdated software and security
If your phone no longer receives OS or security updates, you’re at risk for compatibility issues and security breaches. See How Long Does a Smartphone Last? for brand-specific timelines.
Multiple issues stacking up
If you’ve got a cracked screen, weak battery, and unreliable charging port, fixing all three might cost as much as—or more than—a replacement.
Why refurbished can be the sweet spot
Refurbished devices offer significant savings over new, undergo rigorous testing, and come with warranties. Buying Certified Pre-Owned gives you flagship performance for much less, and you can upgrade sooner without the steep depreciation of a new phone.
When replacement makes the most sense
- Your phone is more than 4–5 years old.
- Repair costs exceed 50–60% of the price of a comparable replacement.
- New software or features are essential to your work or lifestyle.
Save up to 50% on a new phone!
Save big when you shop our selection of Certified Pre-Owned phones. 64-point inspection and a limited lifetime warranty for eligible customers*.
Shop now
Environmental Impact
Globally, over 50 million tonnes of e-waste are generated each year, and less than 20% is recycled properly. Smartphones are a big part of this, containing materials that are harmful when landfilled.
Why repair helps
Repairing delays disposal, reduces the demand for new materials, and lowers the carbon footprint linked to manufacturing. Even extending a device’s life by 12 months can cut its lifetime emissions by 30%.
Why buying CPO helps
Buying refurbished instead of new can reduce your phone’s carbon footprint by up to 75%. Devices are restored, tested, and resold without the need for new production. Learn more from How Buying a Certified Pre-Owned Phone Promotes a Sustainable Environment.
Convenience and Turnaround Time
How quickly you can get back to texting, streaming, or working might be a deciding factor above all else.
- Repairs: Many screen and battery repairs can be done in under an hour in-store. You keep your data, your setup, and your apps exactly how you like them.
- Replacement: Buying in-store means you leave with a device right away, but online purchases may take several days to arrive. Data transfer, app reinstallation, and personalization can add hours.
If you need your phone urgently and the issue is fixable, repair is often the fastest way to get back up and running.
Making the Final Call
Choosing whether to repair or replace your phone comes down to a mix of cost, age, condition, and what you need from it.
Repair is usually the right call if:
- Your phone is under 3–4 years old.
- The issue is limited to one or two components (screen, battery, charging port, camera glass).
- Parts are readily available for your make and model.
- The repair cost is less than half the price of replacing it with a similar model.
- Your device is still receiving OS and security updates.
Replace is generally better if:
- Your phone is 4–5+ years old or nearing the end of software support.
- It has multiple hardware issues or a major component failure.
- The repair cost is more than half the replacement cost.
- You want new features that your current device can’t support.
When it depends:
Some problems — like water damage, Face ID/Touch ID failure, or certain charging port repairs — fall into a grey area. In these cases, weigh the repair estimate and the likelihood of success against the benefits of upgrading.
Bottom line:
If your repair is quick, affordable, and keeps a younger device running strong, fix it. If it’s older, expensive to repair, or can’t do what you need it to, replacing it is the smarter move. For upgrades that don’t break the bank, Certified Pre-Owned devices offer flagship performance, full warranties, and a smaller environmental footprint than buying new.
